ukraine@war

Share this post

Day 465

abdymok.substack.com

Discover more from ukraine@war

Ultra-competitive Ukraine-style Politics
Continue reading
Sign in

Day 465

Ethnogenetic wishy-washiness

pgb
Jun 3, 2023
1
Share this post

Day 465

abdymok.substack.com
Share
Photo c/o abdymok
Ukraine’s cross-border tactics are aimed at destabilizing Russia. Judging by the response, they’re working (CNN, June 3, 2023)

The above analysis by Sam Kiley, CNN Senior International Correspondent, is loopy for a number of reasons. For starters, he hasn’t dropped the “dissident” label. Secondly, most Russians could give a shit about what happens to their compatriots in Belgorod oblast. The same goes for Kursk, Bryansk and maybe Voronezh and Krasnodar (not Krasnodor).

While cross-border raids may boost morale for some in Kyiv, they are probably counterproductive because they fuel enmnity towards Ukraine among Russians. They might have some military value, but no one is sure how much.

We gave Sam a score of minus 15 points on a scale of 1 to 10 for his first reportage on May 25

1
. This second effort is just as meh.

Alya Shandra at Euromaidan Press talks up Russian Volunteer Corps (RDK) leader Aleksandr Fortuna here. The interview exposes what Kirill Rogov describes as the “ideological wishy-washiness” behind the group’s message.

Russian Volunteer Corps fights for Ukraine and to dismantle Putin’s regime (Euromaidan Press, May 30, 2023)

Alya footnootes passionaries, crediting Lev Gumilev, whose ideas about the ethogenisis of Ukrainians were interesting, but, er, dead wrong.

Table of Contents, Geography of Ethnicity in the Historical Period (Lev Gumilev, 1990)

Lev devotes an entire chapter to passionarity starting on page 33. I picked up the book when I was carousing in St. Petersburg in 1991. I’ve beeing reading portions of the manifest every since, usually late at night when I have difficulty falling asleep.

As for RDK, I would refer Sam and Alya to the project’s kick-off presser eight months ago. They should study the video carefully before writing more articles about RDK.

1

Day 456. Apocalypse stories (May 25, 2023)

1
Share this post

Day 465

abdymok.substack.com
Share
Previous
Next
Comments
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 abdymok
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing